US judge rules out IP address evidence in file-sharing case

By
US judge rules out IP address evidence in file-sharing case

Judge accuses prosecution of "fishing trips" by using IP address evidence to identify alleged file-sharers

A US judge has ruled that an IP address does not equate to identifying a person, in a legal ruling that could have far-reaching consequences.

In a case remarkably similar the the infamous ACS Law proceedings, which were thrown out of court in the UK earlier this year, porn company VPR Internationale was seeking the personal addresses of hundreds of alleged illegal file-sharers based on their IP addresses.

Armed with these details, lawyers have chased individuals for payment related to copyright material they are accused of downloading based only on their IP addresses.

The so-called mass lawsuits have been criticised on both sides of the Atlantic – indeed the judge called the exercises “fishing trips”.

The ruling in an Illinois court by Judge Harold Baker could put an end to such practices after he said IP addresses were an insufficient form of ID.

“The infringer might be the subscriber, someone in the subscriber’s household, a visitor with her laptop, a neighbour, or someone parked on the street at any given moment,” Judge Baker said.

The judge cited a recent case in which federal enforcers raided a property to arrest suspects accused of child pornography offences, only to discover that the real perpetrators had been piggy-backing on the network.

The ruling will give further ammunition to rights campaigners on both sides of the Atlantic who have argued that IP address identification – as outlined in the Digital Economy Act, and which could be used to cut off habitual downloaders – should not be used as an identification tool.

This article originally appeared at pcpro.co.uk

Copyright © Alphr, Dennis Publishing
Tags:

Most Read Articles

Windows 10 Fall Creators Update: 10 of the best new features

Windows 10 Fall Creators Update: 10 of the best new features

Australia gets its own Humble Bundle

Australia gets its own Humble Bundle

Ask Graeme - What is the value of the NBN?

Ask Graeme - What is the value of the NBN?

Review: Synology DS718+ NAS

Review: Synology DS718+ NAS

Would you like to receive

Our Newsletter?