Nokia N9 review: is the MeeGo smartphone worth investing in?

Nokia N9 review: is the MeeGo smartphone worth investing in?
Rating
Overall:

A glimpse at greatness finally arrives for Nokia, but is it too late?

Performance:
5
Features & Design:
6
Value For Money:
5
Price
Price: $949
> Pricing info
Browse this Review:   Next

Many readers will remember Nokia as a phone powerhouse, constantly innovating and always the mobile of choice. Sadly, it’s been a while between vodkas for the Finnish once-giant and in the current world of smartphones, the company has suffered at the hands of both its rivals and itself.

So it’s an odd sensation using the Nokia N9, a handset that’s remarkably unlike anything Nokia has done in recent years. As its first (and probably only) MeeGo OS smartphone, the N9 is an impressive and accomplished device.

In terms of raw industrial design, it’s a superbly beautiful handset. The polycarbonate unibody feels fantastic, hitting 12.1mm at its thickest point and getting to just under 116.5mm long.

The 1GHz processor might seem underpowered when contrasted with other phones on the market, but it completed the SunSpider test in 3.695 seconds (compared to the A-Listed Galaxy SII’s 3.3seconds) and loaded the ABC home page in around 8.9 seconds. Not the fastest, but more than adequate. Battery life was also impressive, with 29% remaining after our 1 days tests – according the N9 itself, this is enough for another full day of stand-by power.

Like the iPhone, the N9 has no slots for upgrading memory (it instead comes in 16GB or 64GB formats) and unusually it actually uses micro SIM cards. Finally, there’s even NFC functionality, although this is mainly used for device pairing and will not support transactions or payments.

First we take Harmattan

One of the more unusual elements to the N9 is the “button lite” design - the only hardware buttons are the volume control and the power. Everything else is controlled via the touchscreen.

This is less difficult than it sounds thanks to the remarkably minimalist Harmattan “instance” of MeeGo that is the phone’s OS. The N9 has only three screens: an Events screen that updates with notifications from email, messaging, social media etc; an Application screen where one can choose the desired app; and an Open Applications screen, which displays every currently running app.

If it sounds a little less than intuitive, it is, but it’s also not difficult to adjust to. Closing or reopening apps from the Open Apps screen is simply a matter of tapping on one to bring it back to full screen or holding a finger down on the screen to open the option to close multiple applications. There are no widgets, but there is an inbuilt weather application that runs off the Events screen.

All control within an application or screen is via the touchscreen. To move a running application to the Open Application screen you swipe upwards from the edge of the bezel. To close the app directly swipe down, again from the edge of the bezel – this distinguishes it from a standard in-app finger swipe. It takes a little getting used to, but quickly feels natural.

Barren store?

 Of course, for many, the judge of a phone is the quality and number of its apps. While there’s nothing wrong with the quality, the number of MeeGo apps is relatively small and unlikely to receive any significant boosts without more phones entering the OS ecosystem – and certainly Nokia’s high profile commitment to Windows Phone isn’t likely to help with this.

Similarly, the lack of removable battery and no SD port, combined with the relatively high price, will be a major turn off to many, especially Android users who have become accustomed to a certain degree of freedom in their devices. Sadly, all of these elements stop us from fully recommending the N9 – despite our obvious enjoyment of it.

If anything, the overwhelming sense using the Nokia N9 is one of melancholy - why, oh why didn’t Nokia release something this good earlier? Why didn’t Nokia stick with this in favour of Windows Mobile? This is a superb piece of hardware and the MeeGo/Harmattan OS is simple and elegant - but using it feels a little like watching your favourite actor’s final film before their untimely demise. 

Source: Copyright © PC & Tech Authority. All rights reserved.

Browse this Review:   Next
See more about:  nokia  |  n9  |  phones
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

Hands-on preview: Sony's a7 and a7r cameras 

Hands-on preview: Sony's a7 and a7r cameras

 
AMD Radeon R9 290X price pops up, but is it real? 

AMD Radeon R9 290X price pops up, but is it real?

 
Best Android apps this week 

Best Android apps this week

 
First Look: MSI Z87 Mpower MAX Motherboard 

First Look: MSI Z87 Mpower MAX Motherboard

 
Exclusive First Look: Gigabyte's Z87X-UD3H 

Exclusive First Look: Gigabyte's Z87X-UD3H

 
Comments: 3
michaelmd101
14 October 2011
If you can afford a top-end phone the more open linux-based operating systems like Meego are worth supporting and potentially could draw in a huge pool of linux developers and software (including a lot of individual developers who have so far stayed away from mobile app development because of the ridiculous cost and hassle required by certain other platforms)
... so the number of available Meego apps could potentially grow VERY QUICKLY if this platform becomes more popular.


Comment made about the PC & Tech Authority article:
Nokia N9 review: is the MeeGo smartphone worth investing in??
A glimpse at greatness finally arrives for Nokia, but is it too late?

What do you think? Join the discussion.
amcmo
15 October 2011
Why weren't Nokia at this point several years ago? We might have real choice in great smartphones if that were the case.

Nokia had a smartphone designed before anyone else but didn't think people would be prepared to pay. Biggest dumb-arse decision in mobile phone history!

I still have a soft spot for Nokia (as opposed to the 'hard' I'm supposed to have for Apple according to some:lol: ), but can't see anything in Winphone to convince me to go down that path.

N9 a couple of years ago would potentially have been the basis for some market leading gear, now it seems destined to just be a dead end.

Missed opportunities!
johnus
14 January 2012
I need a comparison between the N9 to lumia 900 There is this thing?
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months










Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads