Battle of the eBook Readers: which is best?

Battle of the eBook Readers: which is best?
Rating
Overall: Not yet rated

Our pick of the bunch? Read on to find out

Size, features and capacity are all important factors when deciding on an eBook reader. So which should you choose?

We've seen a smattering of eBook readers trickle through our Labs, but this year marks the first time that manufacters are seriously including Australia in their eBook plans. As with all handheld devices, there are some important personal decisions to be factored into your choice of reader, sych as size, features, capacity ... and of course, the available book selection.

Our verdict? The Kindle wins out, though it's a close race. Read on to find out why it pips the rest.

 

iRiver Story


The iRiver Story is a likeable device, with a 6in, 600 x 800 E Ink screen set into an attractive matte-white case. Below the screen is a spacious, usable Qwerty keyboard, and to each side of it, flush with the edges of the case, are large page-back and forward keys. Along the bottom edge is a plastic panel covering an SD card slot, a mini-USB port for file transferral and charging, and a 3.5mm headphone socket.

The screen isn’t as good as the other readers here, the background looking greyer and the text less inky, but it’s still perfectly readable. The Story’s menu system is both intuitive and responsive, however.

You can take notes with the keyboard or carry out keyword searches, load up MP3 files to listen to via the 3.5mm headphone socket or the speaker on the rear, and record voice memos with the integrated microphone.

Battery life is the same as with the previous version (quoted at 9,000 page turns) and storage space remains generous – 2GB, plus space via the memory card slot.

Rating: 4/6
Price: $378 
Supplier: JB HiFi
Internet: iRiver

 

Sony Reader Touch Edition PRS-650BC


The Reader Touch is a gorgeous piece of hardware. The front bezel and spine are cool-to-the-touch brushed aluminium, the rear panel has a grippy rubberised plastic coating, and the whole unit feels as if it’s been put together with a craftsman’s fine attention to detail. It’s solid as a rock and feels nicer to hold than the Kindle.

It has 2GB of internal storage, plus twin memory card slots on the top edge for expansion (one for Memory Sticks, one for SD cards). On the bottom edge resides a 3.5mm headphone socket for listening to audiobooks or MP3s, while a stylus is tucked into the top right-hand corner for making notes.

Both the new Sony Readers boast the latest and greatest E Ink Pearl panel, and this puts them on level pegging with the Amazon Kindle. This is complemented by Sony’s replacement of the resistive touchscreen layer coating the E Ink screen on previous Readers with an infrared optical sensor embedded in the screen bezel. This makes the screen much easier on the eye and far less prone to reflective glare. It’s also far more responsive than before.
 

Rating: 5/6
Price: $299  
Supplier: via Sony web site
Internet: Sony

 

Amazon Kindle

 


Amazon has beefed up the specifications on the latest iteration of its popular Kindle reader. It has upped the available storage to just over 3GB and added the new E Ink Pearl panel, which is as comfortable on the eyes as words on a page, even in direct sunlight.

Physically, the device is a little slimmer than its predecessor. Amazon has achieved this by reducing the thickness of the bevel and tweaking the keyboard. Page turn buttons are mounted on the left and right, with forward and back replicated on both sides so you can turn pages one-handed.

The bottom edge of the device sports a volume control and 3.5mm headphone jack (the rear-mounted speakers are surprisingly effective as well) along with a microUSB connector for both charging and data transfer. Finally, there’s a slide/release power switch that incorporates an LED to indicate the charging state. Amazon continues to resist the temptation to adopt touch technology, but the usefulness of touch is a very personal thing.

Battery life is quoted at up to one month with wireless turned off. In the real world, however, Amazon encourages you to keep it switched on so you can store the furthest point reached in a book. This is odd given that all other bookmarking is handled on the device itself and keeping the wireless on has the effect of reducing battery life by at least half. Still, two weeks is perfectly manageable given that the charging time is only around an hour from flat.
 

Rating: 6/6
Price: US$189 (3G) US$139 (WiFi)  
Supplier: Via Amazon.com  
Internet: Amazon

Sony Reader Pocket Edition PRS-350


It would be stretching the bounds of reality to call this truly pocketable – it won’t slip comfortably into the pocket of your jeans like a phone, but it’s lighter and more compact than most paperbacks, and at 104 x 9 x 145mm (WDH) and 155g you can sling it in a bag without a thought for the extra weight or bulk.

That petite frame inevitably means it has a smaller screen than the Touch’s 6in effort, and it also lacks the Touch’s expansion slots and audio capabilities, but in all of the core areas it matches its bigger brother, blow for blow.

In fact, as far as that display is concerned, the Pocket has a slight advantage over its rivals. Since it has the same number of pixels spread over a smaller surface area, the pixel density is higher (200dpi versus 167dpi), and this leads to crisper text edges.

The Pocket Edition is just as accomplished an eBook reader as the bigger Touch. In some ways, it beats it: it’s smaller and lighter and looks a touch sharper. But Sony’s pricing keeps the Pocket Edition more expensive than the Kindle and that makes it a difficult sell.

Rating: 5/6
Price: $229  
Supplier: Via Sony website  
Internet: Sony

Source: Copyright © PC Pro, Dennis Publishing
Copyright © PC Authority, Haymarket Media

See more about:  ebook  |  kindle  |  iriver  |  story  |  sony  |  reader  |  tablet  |  roundup  |  comparison
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

Opinion: Forget Apple, Sony and Amazon is the real battle 

Opinion: Forget Apple, Sony and Amazon is the real battle

 
Telstra wireless broadband reviewed 

Telstra wireless broadband reviewed

 
eBook reader buying guide: Amazon Kindle 3 vs Nook Color vs Sony Reader Touch Edition 

eBook reader buying guide: Amazon Kindle 3 vs Nook Color vs Sony Reader Touch Edition

 
eBook reader buyer's guide: four challengers to the Kindle 

eBook reader buyer's guide: four challengers to the Kindle

 
Comments: 8
smadge1
8 December 2010
Well, I have the Amazon Kindle App for Android. The battery life on my Android tablet Phone probably isn't as good as one of these dedicated readers, but I don't need MORE devices. If I can get eReader apps for more services, I'll be set.


Comment made about the PC & Tech Authority article:
Battle of the eBook Readers: which is best??
Size, features and capacity are all important factors when deciding on an eBook reader. So which should you choose?

What do you think? Join the discussion.
firefox
8 December 2010
I personally own a B&N nook, which I bought before the Amazon Kindle 3 announcement, but after the nook price drop.
I know it's not officially available in Australia, and you need to jump through a few hoops to buy it and any books, but I have found it is much cheaper, fairer and easier to buy from Barnes & Noble than Amazon, Borders or Sony.
At the very least, I would HIGHLY recommend staying away from the iRiver Story, which is a complete rip off stuck in the age before the Kobo and Kindle 3. But what I am wondering is why the Kobo WiFi is not featured?
Ah well, I'm happy with my nook and its touchscreen - better for controlling than buttons in relation to e-Ink, IMO.
prueg
9 December 2010
Should the postage costs be included in the Kindle's price? Or is there somewhere here you can pick one up from, like you can with the other readers?

Would also be interested in your take on the Kogan eReader. Not as fancy as these, but much cheaper.
firefox
13 December 2010
@prueg
1. No the postage costs are extra to the Kindle, but would only be about $20-$30 USD on top of the Kindle.
There is nowhere you can pick one up, as Amazon (maker of the Kindle) has no actual storefront, just warehouses based in America.
marts
1 January 2011
Where are you guys getting your Kindle prices from? The cheapest Kindle costs $135 USD. The next one is $185 USD. The Kindle DX costs around $485. Shipping to Oz is around $25. At least, that is what it cost me. Those prices make the Kindle somewhat more competitive than what your article is alluding to.
Ananaz
13 February 2011


Hmm I think Samsumg has a new eBook. You should give it a look :)
damdo
11 March 2011
I think if you look at only and i mean only ebook reading, then the Barnes and noble nook is a pretty decent buy. However i am more of a multitasking kind of a guy so the Samsung galaxy catches my fancy. Granted it isn't a dyed in wool kind of an ebook reader but still i like for the occasionally reading of books while on my commute. Also heard a lot about this Notion Ink adam device but again it's more of a tablet pc. Seems kind of nice too
stevebin
16 December 2011
It is good for the use But I find that it is much cheaper, more equitable, more easily than the Amazon from Barnes & Noble, Borders or Sony purchase.At least, I would strongly recommend stay away from Avery's story, which is a complete tear up the card before the workshops, and Kindle3 years of age.
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months










Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads