Apple MacBook Pro 15 reviewed: is the new Core i7 model worth buying?

Apple MacBook Pro 15 reviewed: is the new Core i7 model worth buying?
Rating
Overall:

Apple finally upgrades to Core i7, but the design isn’t perfect and Windows users will find battery life short

Performance:
6
Features & Design:
4
Value for money:
2
Price
Price: $3199
> Pricing info
Browse this Review:   Next

The allure of the MacBook Pro is simple. With power enough to please performance die-hards, and the poise to please fashionistas, Apple's flagship laptop was always destined to impress. But, with previous models still chugging along on Core 2 processors, many will have been holding off for this inevitable Core i7 upgrade.

Performance
The price is still enough to put a lump in anyone's throat, but the outlay rewards with the usual Apple delights. The major news is that the slick aluminium chassis is now joined by some up-to-date internals - but, although it's definitely fast, it isn't quite as fast as you might expect. Intel's Core i7-620M is teamed with 4GB of DDR3 memory, propelling it to a fine 1.75 in our benchmarks, but it's still a whisker behind two other recent i7 converts - Sony's VAIO Z11 on 1.80 and Lenovo's ThinkPad T510 (PC Authority, July 2010) on 1.91. The 5400rpm hard disk shares some of the blame; at this price, a 7200rpm disk would seem more appropriate.

Graphics
More interestingly, in a first for Apple, graphical duties are handled by dual GPUs comprising the on-CPU Intel HD graphics and Nvidia's discrete GeForce GT 330M chipset. The burlier chipset of the pair, the GeForce GT 330M, fired through Crysis at 1280 x 1024 and Medium detail with a borderline-playable average of 26fps. Intel's HD graphics, meanwhile, proved man enough for HD video playback.

The duo works wonders in Apple's OS X Snow Leopard, with Intel's HD graphics taking the reins most of the time and the Nvidia chipset automatically stepping in when more graphical muscle is required. Unfortunately, it's a great trick that you'll only appreciate in OS X. It's painfully absent when running Windows.

Battery Life
Boot Camp works as simply as ever for Windows installation, but the Nvidia chipset takes a serious toll on battery life. The Intel HD chip is efficient, and allowed the MacBook Pro 15 to idle for 8hrs 15mins in OS X; by contrast, with the hungrier Nvidia chip permanently engaged, it managed only 3hrs 35mins in Windows. Push the MacBook Pro 15 hard and you'll be dashing to the mains after just 1hr 25mins.

Features
The frugal sprinkling of two USB ports, one FireWire 800 connector, Gigabit Ethernet and an SD card reader proves as limiting as ever, and although the miniature DisplayPort socket accepts a flexible array of adapters - including DisplayPort, HDMI, DVI and D-SUB - the need to shell out for each one is galling.

Screen
Our hope that this, the most expensive MacBook Pro 15, might stretch to a high-definition display was dashed, too. Image quality is superb, with vibrant colours, good contrast and impressive brightness, but the native 1440 x 900 resolution is disappointing. We wouldn't hesitate in upgrading to the HD-capable 1680 x 1050-pixel display for AU$140.

Design
Spending this much, we'd expect unparalleled levels of comfort, but we were a little disappointed. Admittedly, the glass multitouch trackpad is responsive, but the backlit keyboard isn't on the same level. The crisp action makes the short-travel keys palatable, but the chiselled front edge of the laptop dug into our wrists.

If that wasn't enough, the combination of Intel's Core i7 and the MacBook Pro's aluminium construction causes the chassis to reach worrying temperatures. Light usage heated the wristrest enough to leave our palms sweaty, and heavy multitasking had the underside at scorching temperatures.

Conclusion
Familiarity breeds contempt, as the saying goes, and Apple's latest proves a perfect illustration. From afar it's the usual lovely thing, with power and aluminium-framed panache in equal measures. But the specification is stingy, the keyboard mediocre, the lack of graphics switching in Windows is a killer blow, and the cooling system borders on the unworkable. We're long past the days when Apple did style like no other, and have seen too many far better laptops in recent months - such as the VAIO Z11 - to recommend this one.

This Review appeared in the August, 2010 issue of PC & Tech Authority Magazine

Source: Copyright © PC Pro, Dennis Publishing

Browse this Review:   Next
See more about:  apple  |  macbook  |  pro  |  15
 
 

Latest Comments

Latest Competitions

Win! Destiny 

Win! Destiny

We're giving away a copy of next great console shooter!
Win! 300 Rise of an Empire 

Win! 300 Rise of an Empire

We're giving away five awesome prize packs!
 

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months










Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads