Head to Head - TomTom ONE (V4) vs Navman S150

Head to Head - TomTom ONE (V4) vs Navman S150
Rating
Overall: Not yet rated

Navman or TomTom? We tested the best selling units in a head to head battle to see which would get us home faster and with less hassle.

Navman S150:
3
TomTom ONE (V4):
6
Browse this Review:   Next
TomTom and Navman have long sought to be the top GPS condenders for consumers in Australia. TomTom in particular have won multiple awards from various publications and that includes our own A-list, for which they have been awarded the last 3 years in a row. Naturally, we decided that the only fair test would be drive the exact same route and see which got us there better and how easy it was to navigate and use the units.

Design

The Navman S150 is the second cheapest of the newly released Navman Platinum S–series range, which also includes the S300t, the S200 and the S100. The form factor on these new units is great; the S150 is light (150g), stylishly thin (13.5 mm) and the 'Super flat' screen is large enough to make viewing maps a breeze (4.3").

The TomTom ONE (known as TomTom ONE V4 in some places and that's how we like to refer to it) is tiny by comparison – but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The ONE’s biggest asset is the demure, fits-in-your-pocket size advantage. It’s almost as light as the S150 (174g) but slightly thicker (25mm vs. 15mm on the Navman), lacking the lean contours of the S150’s slick iPod-like design. We’re the first to admit that the ONE's screen is rather small (3.5”) – perhaps too cramped for some. It looks micro in comparison to the S150’s expansive widescreen.

Accessories

The new TomTom ONE also comes with the nifty EasyMount system, which we can’t say enough good things about. Connecting the unit to your windscreen is a simple procedure – the type we wish other GPS manufacturers would learn to adopt. The suction cap can be carried around with the unit, and it’s still sleek enough to fit into a jeans pocket. The Navman’s suction mount is a hulking piece of equipment and you can forget about stuffing it in your pocket. The design is nice though; the GPS will stay on its bracket, but we feel it’s too big for portability.

Interface

This is the area that Navman disappointed us the most. The S150 is an improvement over previous models, but it’s nothing to get too excited about, because the interface is still too painful to navigate. During breaks in traffic, we found it hard to access quick rerouting options - you’ll need to press the screen in exactly the right spot otherwise it could trigger a part of the map or open up the POI directory by mistake. It just a little complex for its own good.

It's even harder to cycle through the Navman menus without needing a fair amount of patience. It took us some time to get used to the many pull-down and pull-across menus that become confusing when you press the wrong spot on the screen.

The S150 touchscreen needs a bit of work too. Navman call it ‘pioneering software with glide touchscreen’, though whichever way one attempts to sugarcoat the finer details, we still found the screen movements a little clunkier and harder to use than the TomTom.

By comparison, the TomTom menu system is probably what makes their models so universally liked. There is nothing difficult about clicking between menus on the TomTom. It’s painless and joyous - praise worth heaping on any GPS.

The ONE touchscreen is excellent: inputing data onto the keyboard appears natural and intuitive. The TomTom models are built around a ‘one-click’ system. Whenever you click on the map, you are taken directly to the main menu, where it’s very simple to find what you need from there.

While the S150 may have more advanced features such as 3D lane guidance and 3D landmarks (nice, but only useful in the big inner cities) – all the extra whistles and bells are worth very little when simple menu functions feel over-complicated. The TomTom ONE is so simple to use, that you should be confident enough to take it out of the box and begin using it immediately after without any hassles.

Maps

Navman now use NAVTEQ maps, while TomTom continue to stick with the WhereIs maps. To be fair, we found that there is little to be concerned about with either maps – it’s hard to spot any real differences. Don't be fooled by marketing that tells you otherwise - both map providers are very good and either one will take you where you need to go. In fact, during our testing, the map data was virtually identical for both map providers. Besides, it isn’t the maps which dictate entirely how we get to our destination (although that is a factor) – it’s the GPS’s actual routing engine that handles this area. It’s quite possibly the most important part of our testing.


( -continued on next page - )

Browse this Review:   Next
See more about:  tomtom  |  one  |  navman  |  s150  |  gps
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

Breaking News: iOS 5 beta "causes iPad to overheat" 

Breaking News: iOS 5 beta "causes iPad to overheat"

 
Comments: 8
Noops
18 December 2008
Considering Garmin units are better than both of these, why was Garmin ommitted? I have a Garmin and have experienced a Tomtom, and the Garmin is "Streets" ahead (pun intended).


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Head to Head - TomTom ONE (V4) vs Navman S150?
Navman or TomTom? We tested the best selling units in a head to head battle to see which would get us home faster and with less hassle.

What do you think? Join the discussion.
Pacman
19 December 2008
Honestly, do you really think Garmin has anything for $250 that even stands upto the value of the TOMTOM ONE? Because, I really really doubt it. If Garmin is so much better, please tell.
Noops
19 December 2008
Well, if price is the ONLY factor, you'll get what you pay for. I have a Garmin, my son has a Tomtom One. My son keeps saying how poor the Tomtom is and keeps asking to borrow my Garmin. Besides, battery life on a Tomtom is well known to be useless - the battery on my son's Tomtom lasts only 10 minutes, and that was from new. As I said, you get what you pay for.
SA Penguin
20 December 2008
Ho Hum. The most important factor, glossed over in the article, is the quality of the maps. Aussie maps are fine- it's when you travel overseas that the "fun" begins. Particularly in Asia.

Michael Palin did a documentary, where he travelled through all the countries that border on the Pacific Ocean- starting in Russia. Try duplicating that feat- you'll be stuck before you even start. Garmin, TomTom- they're all pathetic at Asian coverage. The closest I've found (and still with plenty of room for improvement) is... Nokia !
jetals
21 December 2008
On aspect of buying a sat-nave is the cost of buying map upgrades.
We have a Navman. During a recent trip to Queensland, we were misdirected because of changes to the roads.
When we got homr, I looked at upgrading the map. WHAT A RIPOFF - $170.00
I defy anyone to justify the cost of the upgrades. This is a very significant part of the price of a new item.
They have to change the maps anyway so that new units can be sold with accurate maps, so why do current owners get ripped off so much???
ziggyzap
22 December 2008
I've tried many GPS units over the years and overall, TomTom leaves the rest for dead. I currently run TomTom Navigator 7 on my Windows Mobile based PDA phone, which gives me all of the facilities of a top of the range TomTom GPS. The beauty of this is that my PDA phone always comes with me, so it never gets left in the car for somebody to steal. The windscreen mount is obviously not for a GPS, so thieves ignore it. I can refer to the maps wherever I go, even by foot, without carrying a separate GPS unit around. As long as I can get TomTom Navigator on my PDA phone, there is no way I will ever get a standalone GPS receiver.
geller
23 December 2008
jetals, what type of map upgrade do you mean? I'm under the impression most map providers constantly release incremental upgrades to their maps (Navtech does this every 3 months) - in the case of navtech these incremental upgrades are free.
jetals
30 December 2008
Hi Geller. I went to the navman web site & looked for maps/upgrades, & the links took me to http://www.navman.com/in-car/3294/Australia/Navman-Australia/Updates/Maps/
Free upgrades would be great
Cheers
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months










Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads