Friday May 16, 2008 2:11 PM AEST
Skip Navigation LinksPC Authority > Reviews > Peripherals > Hard Disks > Western Digital MyBook Studio Edition

Search Reviews

Find more like...

Review Categories > Hard Disks
Price > $400 - $450
Manufacturer > Western Digital
Awards > Labs Winner
Review Scores > 5
Features & Design > 6
Performance > 6
Value for money > 4
Article Types > Review
Magazine Issues > May
Authors > Darien Graham-Smith
Tags > drive , Freecom , LaCie , Mac

Western Digital MyBook Studio Edition

Hard Disks | Western Digital | http://www.westerndigital.com.au




Western Digital MyBook Studio Edition
Performance:  6
Features & Design:  6
Value for money:  4
Overall Rating: 
User Rating:  No user ratings.
May 9, 2008
Tags: Western | | Digital | MyBook | Studio | Edition
Labs Winner
RRP: $422 (time of review)
Check the latest prices.


A solid, assured drive with plenty of interfaces and enough style to justify the price.
The MyBook Studio Edition is designed principally with the Mac market in mind, as evidenced by its silver design and the Mac-focused instructions that accompany it. But it works perfectly well with a PC, and it stands out from the crowd this month as a classy performer.

The MyBook may look dumpy next to the monolithic LaCie or the low-profile Freecom, but its chunky shape means it’s easy to stand it upright, and some thought has clearly gone into dispelling any impression of boxiness. Different corners are rounded in different ways, which gives it a pleasingly asymmetrical profile, and the narrow LED strip at the front glows to indicate it’s powered. In use, it strobes back and forth like the bonnet light on KITT.

Round the back, there’s a standard mini-USB connector, plus eSATA and – another indicator of the MyBook’s Apple heritage – two nine-pin FireWire 800 ports. There’s a cable provided to connect these to a six-pin FireWire 400 socket (the type most commonly found on PCs and notebooks) but, annoyingly, there’s no eSATA cable provided. There’s a power button, too, but when we tried it we found the drive immediately woke up again. We had to physically detach the USB cable to get the unit to properly power down.

While the MyBook Studio exudes confidence, it does fall down in one area – it’s the most expensive desktop drive on test in terms of unit price, although 42c per gigabyte is reasonable. It isn’t a close race, either: Iomega offers the same capacity for $41 less. You could save a little by opting for the slightly cheaper MyBook Home Edition (it’s black and lacks FireWire 800, which PC users won’t miss) but you’re paying that money for a solid build and no small amount of style.

At the end of the day, the MyBook is a huge drive with eSATA support that’ll look stunning on your desk. If you think that’s worth paying for, you won’t be disappointed.

This article appeared in the May, 2008 issue of PC Authority.


Ads by Google

Your Say
Be the first to comment on this article.

Login or register to submit a comment.

Related Products

WESTERN DIGITAL WD2000JB CAVIAR & IBM DESKSTAR 180GXP

WESTERN DIGITAL WD2000JB CAVIAR & IBM DESKSTAR 180GXP

While the storage community eagerly awaits Serial ATA disks (see page 39), the latest generations of...

WESTERN DIGITAL Caviar WD2500JD (250GB/SATA)

WESTERN DIGITAL Caviar WD2500JD (250GB/SATA)

Western Digital markets this drive as a special edition drive for higher performance needs, but in o...

Western Digital My Book 500GB

Western Digital My Book 500GB

Why is this external hard drive different from all other external hard drives?

Pinnacle Studio 11

Pinnacle Studio 11

4

HD editing finally heads to the desktop in this major update to a favourite consumer editing package...

Most Discussed

Sony DSLR-A700

Sony DSLR-A700 (11 comments)

How does Sony's new DSLR stack up against the like of Nikon and Canon? The A700 has excellent image quality, but is let down by design quirks and the high price

Sony PlayStation 3

Sony PlayStation 3 (7 comments)

Video support isn’t the best, but the PS3 remains a superb piece of kit

HTC Touch Dual

HTC Touch Dual (5 comments)

A phone with a personality crisis, but although it’s no iPhone it makes an interesting choice for business users

Gigabyte Nvidia GeForce 9600 GT, is new ultimate mid-range card

Gigabyte Nvidia GeForce 9600 GT, is new ultimate mid-range card (5 comments)

The 9600 GT redefines the mainstream graphics market, offering high-end power at a mid-range price. At this price we want one.

FIRST LOOK: Samsung Live Loud SGH-i450

FIRST LOOK: Samsung Live Loud SGH-i450 (4 comments)

A ‘two-way slider’ phone that feels a little like an iPod and has a speaker for your tunes. Samsung tries to get you to do away with your MP3 player.

Philips Streamium SLM5500

Philips Streamium SLM5500 (2 comments)

A reasonable option if your budget is tight, but you get what you pay for


PC Authority A-List
PC Authority Rated
User Rated
Maxtor OneTouch 4 Mini

Maxtor OneTouch 4 Mini

Review Score 6 out of 6

A clever, convenient little drive that you can carry around with you in your pocket.

Western Digital MyBook Studio Edition

Western Digital MyBook Studio Edition

Review Score 5 out of 6

A solid, assured drive with plenty of interfaces and enough style to justify the price.

Seagate Barracuda ES.2

Seagate Barracuda ES.2

Review Score 5 out of 6

Monster storage; plus a choice of professional SAS or consumer SATA interfaces and reliability to boot.