Rival slams Google's "inconsistent" antitrust evidence

Rival slams Google's "inconsistent" antitrust evidence

Price comparison site rips into Eric Schmidt over written testimony.

Price comparison site Foundem has accused Google boss Eric Schmidt of “inconsistencies and inaccuracies” in statements submitted to an investigation into alleged anticompetitive practices.

Foundem claims it was penalised at the expense of Google's own product search tools – and is one of several companies that called for competition hearings on both sides of the Atlantic looking into “search neutrality”.

According to Foundem, Schmidt gave confusing answers to the Senate Antitrust Committee in a hearing back in September, and has added to the confusion in written responses submitted to follow-up questions.

“A few of Mr Schmidt’s written answers seem gratuitously evasive,” the company said on its Search Neutrality blog.

“Many are markedly at odds with Google’s existing documents and prior statements. And some are just plain wrong. The significant inconsistencies and inaccuracies in Mr Schmidt’s testimony at the hearing have only been amplified by those in his written answers.”

Foundem survey data was used during the senate hearing to highlight what the company claims were favourable results rankings for Google's Product Search, which appeared higher than rival price comparison sites.

According to Foundem, Schmidt played down the issue by claiming Google's product search was not a price comparison tool, despite the fact that its own listings refer to it as “Google's UK price comparison service”.

“In the hearing, Mr Schmidt ducked several of Senator Lee’s questions about the troubling findings of this study with the bizarre claim that Google Product Search is not a price comparison service," Foundem said.

However, in his written response, Foundem says Schmidt had changed his tune, claiming: “Google product search is a type of thematic search that allows consumers to compare prices and see which websites are selling a particular product.”

According to Foundem, such tactics were helping Google to confuse the regulators looking into the allegation of search manipulaton.

In hearings and in public, Google has denied favouring its own products in results, but has yet to respond to a request for comments on the latest accusations.

This article originally appeared at pcpro.co.uk

Source: Copyright © PC Pro, Dennis Publishing

See more about:  rival  |  slams  |  googles
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

100 games to play before you die 

100 games to play before you die

 
Best Android apps this week 

Best Android apps this week

 
New Kira Ultrabook is a stylish, aspirational gem, according to Toshiba 

New Kira Ultrabook is a stylish, aspirational gem, according to Toshiba

 
THQ files for bankruptcy, business as usual 

THQ files for bankruptcy, business as usual

 
Top 25 apps for Android tablets 

Top 25 apps for Android tablets

 

Latest Comments

Latest Competitions

Experience The Evil Within at an exclusive VIP event! 

Experience The Evil Within at an exclusive VIP event!

10 VIPs will win a place at this exclusive event to get hands on time with Bethesda's upcoming horror title.
Win! Godzilla Prize Packs 

Win! Godzilla Prize Packs

STOMP ALL THE THINGS.
Win! Batman: Assault on Arkham 

Win! Batman: Assault on Arkham

Na na na na na na na WIN STUFF!
Win! Destiny 

Win! Destiny

We're giving away a copy of next great console shooter!
Win! 300 Rise of an Empire 

Win! 300 Rise of an Empire

We're giving away five awesome prize packs!
 

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months










Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads