Sorry Apple, but Siri runs fine on an iPhone 4

Sorry Apple, but Siri runs fine on an iPhone 4

Hacker shows that Apple's new voice assistant runs perfectly well on older handsets.

Apple's claims that its new voice assistant, Siri, needs the dual-core processing power of the iPhone 4S have been disputed by an enterprising hacker.

Siri is one of the few new features of iOS 5 that have been withheld from owners of older iPhone handsets, with Apple claiming they don't have enough processing grunt to cope - even though the actual transcribing of voice commands is performed on Apple's servers, not the handset itself.

However, the 9to5Mac blog has posted a video of Siri running on a jailbroken iPhone 4. The video shows the single-core iPhone 4 responding to Siri commands at exactly the same speed as the 4S, undermining Apple's claims, although it's not shown what impact running Siri on the iPhone 4 has on the handset's battery life.

The hacker got Siri running on the iPhone 4 by using "files from an iPhone 4S which aren’t ours to distribute".

"It also requires a validation token from the iPhone 4S that has to be pulled live from a jailbroken iPhone 4S, and it’s about a 20-step process right now," Steven Troughton-Smith told 9to5Mac.

Troughton-Smith also managed to get Siri running on a fourth-generation iPod touch, but claims the "the microphone on the iPod is nowhere near as good as the iPhone," meaning users have to raise the voices and speak much more clearly to make the voice assistant work on the device.

Although Apple is unlikely to reverse its position on porting Siri to older handsets and Troughton-Smith wants no part in distributing an illegal workaround, he says he has "no doubts that others will package this up and distribute it quasi-illegally, or try and sell it to people".

This article originally appeared at pcpro.co.uk

Source: Copyright © PC Pro, Dennis Publishing

See more about:  sorry  |  apple  |  siri  |  runs  |  fine  |  iphone
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

Five killer features of BlackBerry 10 

Five killer features of BlackBerry 10

 
Google Maps not coming to iOS 6 anytime soon 

Google Maps not coming to iOS 6 anytime soon

 
Photos: Google's Project Glass 

Photos: Google's Project Glass

 
In Pictures: (Almost) Live from Mars 

In Pictures: (Almost) Live from Mars

 
In Pictures: Amazing tech projects from Microsoft's Imagine Cup  

In Pictures: Amazing tech projects from Microsoft's Imagine Cup

 
Comments: 4
cootified
2 November 2011
Curious as to why he is demoing this via Wifi and not a cellular connection...?


Comment made about the PC & Tech Authority article:
Sorry Apple, but Siri runs fine on an iPhone 4?
Hacker shows that Apple's new voice assistant runs perfectly well on older handsets.

What do you think? Join the discussion.
j876
2 November 2011
Siri is just a bit of software of course it can be ported to older handsets. Apple doesn't want to do it otherwise they won't sell as many iPhone 4S phones. It is a commercial decision morew than technical.
DJ...
2 November 2011
"Commercial decision more than a technical".
I doubt that, although commercial considerations probably do come into it a little.. One thing that distinguishes Apple from a PC vendor is "quality". PC vendors and their users are too focussed on price to see value. Apple prefers to err on the side of providing a very good user experience which includes speed and completeness of service. Siri running on an iPhone 4 does not provide the full user experience that is "SIRI" and therefore customers who use it on an iPhone 4 may decry its true worth because they aren't getting the whole enchilada.
amcmo
8 November 2011
Word is Apple are working on Siri for the 4. No word on whether it's a new version for the older phone or if updates of Siri will work better on the older device.
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

Which broadband network do you think is the best choice for Australia?



or View results
The Coalition's.
  19%
 
Labor's.
  63%
 
Screw this I'm going back to smoke signals and string on a can.
  18%
TOTAL VOTES: 1672

Vote now
Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads