eBook reader buying guide: Amazon Kindle 3 vs Nook Color vs Sony Reader Touch Edition

eBook reader buying guide: Amazon Kindle 3 vs Nook Color vs Sony Reader Touch Edition

Which eBook reader should you buy? Here's what you need to know when comparing the Amazon Kindle 3 against the Sony Reader Touch Edition (PRS-650) and Barnes & Noble NookColor

eBook Readers are one of the hottest gadgets to appear in recent years. They are a book worm’s best friend, a traveler’s lifeblood and a student’s companion. Capable of storing thousands of digital books at once, they are the must-have gadget for readers on the move.

There are currently dozens of different eBook readers competing for your wallet’s dollar – enough to fill a small bookcase, in fact. While some of these models are pretty basic, others come with all sorts of additional bells-and-whistles, including inbuilt Wi-Fi, picture viewing, MP3 support and colour/touch screen displays. Some, like the NookColor, even provide a tablet-style experience similar to the Apple iPad.

Three of the more popular eBook readers currently on the market are the Amazon Kindle 3 (3G Wi-Fi), Barnes & Noble Nook Color and Sony Reader Touch Edition (PRS-650). Each model comes with its own unique selling points, as well as a few singular flaws. If you’re looking to buy an eBook reader, you could certainly do worse than one of these models – but how do they compare? Let’s take a look at each in turn.

Barnes & Noble NookColor

 The Barnes & Noble NookColor is a high-end eReader that boasts a great deal of functionality. Its main claim to fame is a 7in touch screen that can display up to 16 million colours. As you’d expect, the addition of colour opens up a whole new range of reading possibilities. In addition to traditional black-and-white text, you can use the NookColor to view university text books, e-mags, digital comics and even children’s picture books.

Other highlights include inbuilt WiFi, MP4 video playback and a MicroSD memory card slot. It also doubles as a portable web-browsing device, similar to the Apple iPad. The NookColor runs off the Android 2.1 platform and offers a wide range of eBook file support (EPUB, PDF, XLS, DOC, PPT, PPS, TXT, DOCM, XLSM, PPTM, PPSX, PPSM, DOCX, XLX, PPTX).

Unlike eBooks with e-ink displays, the NookColor can be viewed in the dark without the need for a light accessory (the screen works just like a regular PC tablet). The display boasts a native resolution of 1024x600, which isn’t too shabby for a seven-inch screen.

In addition to a MicroSD card slot, the NookColor comes with 8GB of inbuilt memory. According to Barnes & Noble, this is enough to store 1000 books, 25 full-colour magazines, 10 newspapers, 50 picture books, 500 songs, and 150 photos.   

The NookColor's LCD display opens up new reading possibilities.

Naturally, all this added functionality doesn’t come cheap: at US$249, the NookColor is significantly more expensive than any other eBook.      

The NookColour benefits from an intuitive interface that is easy to get to grips with. Viewing quality is exceptional and the touch screen works well. Reflectivity is surprisingly minimal for an LCD screen – even in direct sunlight. That said, the Kindle 3 and Sony Reader Touch Edition both performed better in this area, with zero glare.

Pros: Colour screen provides new reading possibilities, user-friendly interface, lots of additional features.

Cons: Expensive

Conclusion: If you’d like to do more than read books with your eReader – and don’t mind spending a bit extra – the Barnes & Noble NookColour is a standout.

Amazon Kindle 3 (3G Wi-Fi edition)

The first Kindle, which debuted in late 2007, was a colossal success for Amazon; selling out in just five-and-a-half hours. It single-handedly kick-started the whole eBook craze, much like the iPad did for tablets in 2010. The latest version, Kindle 3, adds 3G connectivity, improved battery life and a revamped 6in e-ink ‘Pearl’ display.  

With dimensions of 190×123×8.5mm, the Kindle 3 is one of the more portable eBooks on the market (it's around 3/4 the size of the original Kindle). It will easily slip inside a briefcase or laptop bag for easy carrying. If you like to read for extended periods of time, the Kindle 3’s slim design is definitely a big plus. The display can also be viewed in direct sunlight without any glare – just like a regular novel.

One of the biggest advantages of the Kindle 3 is that it grants you access to Amazon’s Kindle Bookstore: home to over 810000 digital publications. Thanks to its 3G connectivity, the Kindle 3 is capable of downloading and purchasing books from anywhere with mobile service. This is especially convenient for travelers, for whom Wi-Fi access may not always be available.

In addition to viewing eBooks, the Kindle 3 can be used to listen to music, read PDF files and view JPEG photos [note: photos and PDFs appear in black-and-white]. You can also share book passages and quotes with friends via the built-in Twitter and FaceBook tools. 

The Amazon Kindle is still one of the slimmest eBooks on the market.

The Kindle 3’s QWERTY keyboard works well – it will be especially appreciated by older users who may not be accustomed to touch screen displays. This makes the Kindle 3 a good gift option for grandparents. The e-ink ‘Pearl’ display is very easy on the eyes and the page refresh rate is impressively speedy.

Kindle 3 comes with 4GB of internal memory, which is enough to store around 3500 books. Unfortunately, there are no external memory options.

Pros: 3G connectivity, speedy interface, portable size

Cons: No external memory

Conclusion: The Kindle 3 (3G Wi-Fi edition) is a good option for people who want a fuss-free, easy-to-use eBook reader. It’s fast, versatile and highly portable.  

NEXT PAGE: Sony Reader Touch Edition, specs comparison and conclusion...

Browse this article:   Next

Source: Copyright © PC & Tech Authority. All rights reserved.

See more about:  ebooks  |  kindle  |  nookcolor
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

50 Essential Online Services 

50 Essential Online Services

 
World of Tanks Blitz screens 

World of Tanks Blitz screens

 
A real archer on the accuracy of in-game bow-shooting 

A real archer on the accuracy of in-game bow-shooting

 
Unboxed: Apple's latest 27in iMac 

Unboxed: Apple's latest 27in iMac

 
Star Wars 1313 gamescom screenshots 

Star Wars 1313 gamescom screenshots

 
Comments: 6
andrys
27 February 2011
Nicely balanced article.
I have both the Kindle and NookColor and do like both for different needs.

The table has an error in that the Kindle very much has had web browsing since 2007. It's also 3G and the web browsing (unlimited except by loading time for complex pages) is free to the Kindle owner. Amazon pays it.

Strangely, many don't know about it. As an e-Ink browser, it's quite a bit slower and we so we use mobile-oriented URLs most.
The web browsing feature is available on 3G in about 60 countries. And with WiFi, the web browsing is faster. Where 3G web-browsing is limited (about 40 countries vs 60 that have it), Amazon offers free Wikipedia.

Supported files: Indirectly supported are Word Doc and HTMl. Amazon does an automated conversion when you email a doc file to your Kindle.

- Andrys, kindleworld.blogspot.com




Comment made about the PC & Tech Authority article:
eBook reader buying guide: Amazon Kindle 3 vs Nook Color vs Sony Reader Touch Edition?
Which eBook reader should you buy? Here's what you need to know when comparing the Amazon Kindle 3 against the Sony Reader Touch Edition (PRS-650) and Barnes & Noble NookColor

What do you think? Join the discussion.
Deonast
27 February 2011
Bit sad that the nook running android doesn't support open document formats. Perhaps open source open formats was a bit much to ask for. Has epub that's something. Problem with docx support is standards wise it is a moving target.
tahunasky
1 March 2011
I have owned a sony prs-650 since oct. I purchased in new york. I was mostly (i dont think the 2 weeks or 10,000 page turns are correct - more like 1 week) very happy with it until 2 days ago, when it stopped working. Phoned sony AU today as i was told it had an international warranty when i purchased. Sony AU informed me that because i didnt have a "travellers warranty card" (which i need to ask for at time of purchase) i can not get it repaired for free in AU. When i said i wasnt told about the need for the "traveller warranty card", sonys reponse was the sales person probably didnt know about it, but if you had of bought it from a sonystyle store they would have told you. The company i bought it form in NYC is an authorised sony dealer. This is the first time i have every heard of this or needed anything like this in all the years i have purchased electronic equipment.
The woman also told me that they have had alot of problems with this model..
So for all you who maybe wanting to purchase the sony ebook reader - buyer beware !!!
markmcla64
8 March 2011
Why not at least list the other eBook readers? Especially since they are probably a heck of a lot cheaper than the ones you did review. The one I bought recently - in Australia - was easily affordable for most people at $79 and it even plays music & movies.
rubaiyat
8 March 2011
Deonast wrote:
Bit sad that the nook running android doesn't support open document formats. Perhaps open source open formats was a bit much to ask for. Has epub that's something. Problem with docx support is standards wise it is a moving target.


Now that Borders and Angus & Roberston have gone into administration, it is a precautionary warning to consider open formats. Indeed open or secure hardware as well.

I would not recommend docx for the above reasons. Stick to ePub or .pdf with .odf as a maybe.
firefox
12 May 2011
ePub is supported on the nook as the most common method because it is reflowable as well as open. There's little point in supporting a standard with a fixed page size and therefore viewable on a single device properly without conversion which is glitchy and time-consuming, whereas ePub is actually good for eReaders.
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

Which side are you choosing in the new console wars?



or View results
The Xbox One
  24%
 
The PlayStation 4
  30%
 
A console? Good Lord no - PC for me thanks!
  46%
TOTAL VOTES: 158

Vote now
Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads