PC Building: Why USB 3 flash drives don't exist

PC Building: Why USB 3 flash drives don't exist

One of the more exciting potential uses of USB 3 is speeding up the humble flash drive. Thanks to a chat with Corsair we now know just why they haven't started to appear yet.

Time to market for new IO technologies has always been a painful thing to watch. Excitement over technology announcements and standard ratification usually quickly gives way to a Mexican standoff between those who make the host hardware and those who make stuff that plugs into it.

Lag time
SATA and USB have been two technologies plagued by such a lag time. When Serial ATA was first introduced, for example, it took over a year from the first controller chips appearing on motherboards until the first drives hit the market. Even those making the motherboard lacked drives to test them with.

The USB 3 push
We have been seeing massive pushes towards USB 3 by big hardware manufacturers like Gigabyte and ASUS. We have seen several products turn up in the PC Authority labs that have fancy logos and plugs ready to accept USB 3 devices, yet so far there have been but a handful of external hard drives that actually use the technology.

We had suspected that the reason holding back other USB 3 products had been Intel's delay in incorporating it into its chipsets. Apparently this isn't the only thing stopping the flow of USB 3 products.

Why flash drives aren't USB 3 yet
During a Corsair event today the question was asked of its Vice President of Marketing, Jim Carlton, of why its range of Flash drives wasn't going USB 3 yet. Apparently there are two issues. Currently the speed limitations on thumb drive transfers come from the Flash chips themselves. In order to deliver throughput that can even touch that of USB 3 the chips need to be run in a quad channel configuration.

Currently this is only found on the Flash Voyager GTR range from Corsair. This is still a USB 2.0 based product however. So why isn't it using USB 3?

Apparently the other major limit on USB 3 flash drives is the USB controller itself. Most thumb drive manufacturers use third party controllers, and at the moment the only one on the market is made by Marvell. Marvell only supplies basic firmware with the controller, which makes it quite hard for manufacturers to use it without serious software engineering. As more companies come onboard with controller designs then it is likely we will see USB 3 flash drives appearing in the market.

See more about:  usb  |  flash  |  storage
 
 
Comments: 2
petergaskin
17 April 2010
It wont stop me from making sure that my next pc has usb3 instead of usb2. i dont fancy having a pc without usb3 for the next 3-4 years. i believe that unlike bluray, most usb items will end up being usb3 only. Try buying an item today that will work with usb1.1 or even usb 1!
No I will not add a card to provide this function. I prefer my pc to have it already installed!



Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Why USB 3 flash drives don't exist?
One of the more exciting potential uses of USB 3 is speeding up the humble flash drive. Thanks to a chat with Corsair we now know just why they haven't started to appear yet.

What do you think? Join the discussion.
Slatts
25 April 2010
John Gillooly wrote:
SATA and USB have been two technologies plagued by such a lag time. When Serial ATA was first introduced, for example, it took over a year from the first controller chips appearing on motherboards until the first drives hit the market. Even those making the motherboard lacked drives to test them with.

You're comparing apples to cheese there John.

When SATA and USB first appeared there was no base of older tech that would run on them.

Any USB 1, 1.1 or 2.0 device will plug into a USB 3 port and work.

A more accurate comparison would be to an increase in speed of RAM. It'd run on a motherboard that didn't support its speed at the fastest speed that the board did support or, conversely, an older but similar family stick will run in a newer higher spec MB at the RAMS fastest speed. (we'll ignore over clocking here.)

I'm betting on USB sockets, if not devices, going mainstream quickly.
I'm also betting that the higher capacity memsticks go USB 3 quickly as well.

That said, it takes a brave man (or a fool) to make tech predictions.8-[

Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Competitions

Win a PC copy of DEFIANCE plus a Hellbug figurine and messenger bag! 

Win a PC copy of DEFIANCE plus a Hellbug figurine and messenger bag!

Win a Defiance prize pack and join the fight now!
 

Latest Poll

Which broadband network do you think is the best choice for Australia?



or View results
The Coalition's.
  19%
 
Labor's.
  63%
 
Screw this I'm going back to smoke signals and string on a can.
  19%
TOTAL VOTES: 1634

Vote now
Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads