My life with Linux special edition: Going back to Linux with Ubuntu Netbook Remix

My life with Linux special edition: Going back to Linux with Ubuntu Netbook Remix

After declaring his 7 day experiment with Linux over, David Fearon treks back into wild Linux country one more time, but returns somewhat disappointed

And so this column is coming to you courtesy of Ubuntu. But not just any Ubuntu, it's the Netbook Remix, and I'm typing this on a wee little Asus Eee PC. I said I'd try the latest build of desktop Ubuntu a couple of months back, but this looked a lot more fun. And it has an interesting name.

The good news is that there is nothing - absolutely nothing - fundamentally wrong with this operating system. And in that respect it's just great. Pop it on a bootable flash drive - the website will show you how - reboot and away you go.

All the hardware on the Asus netbook works beautifully, a happy result of the fact that netbooks are mostly based on only a handful of variations on the same hardware. Working wireless, correct screen resolution, everything. Even the webcam works straight off.

The basis of the Netbook Remix is a sort of bolt-on interface that takes over the whole screen and presents you with nice, easy shortcuts to get to the usual netbook applications: web browsing, office tasks, media playing. It works too.

The interface itself is pretty, or at least something approaching pretty. At any rate, it's cohesive and avoids the typical rambling Linux menus larded with near-identical applications.

Superficially, this is really quite exciting: a proper, easy-to-use netbook version of Linux that looks good and has ease of use on its side.

And coming from Ubuntu it bears the authority of a brand name, in an area of computing that's barely heard of the idea. It's a rallying cry for those blood-stained, tear-streaked Linux warriors still binding their wounds after a near-total shift from Linux to Windows on netbooks.

But those Linuxy people do have this terribly determined habit of blundering off and sticking their own spear in their foot wherever possible, and over such tragically obvious things.



Owners of the original HTC Touch smartphone - with its TouchFLO 3D interface slapped on top of Windows Mobile - will know that there's nothing as disappointing as a beautifully slick UI that's only a millimetre thick.

And with the Netbook Remix the transparency, slick animations and general coolness last for precisely as long as it takes to click an icon. The breathtakingly ugly Linux Monster then jumps out at you clutching a wet haddock, slaps you across the face with it and sits on your head, laughing.

click to view full size imageJust try clicking on the Rhythmbox music player, for instance. Actually, don't: it's too awful and I wouldn't want to inflict the trauma on anyone.

Another example: the default format for OpenOffice Writer documents is ODT, the OpenOffice Document Text format. Those open standards, intended to forge the way ahead to a new future free of proprietary lock-in, are admirable. But they're as much use as a dictionary to Katie Price when it comes to sending your mum your Christmas list.

Try this simple test: write something in OpenOffice and email it to the friend or relative of your choice. Now sit back and wait for hilarity to ensue when they think they can't open the stupid thing.

Making ODT the default is a classic example of geek idealism overcoming common sense.

OpenOffice even retains Clippy the paperclip - a character Microsoft wisely abandoned years ago - in the mutated form of an irritating and wholly bizarre cartoon chimera made of a lightbulb and a lifebuoy.

He pops up when he thinks you need help, or simply to let you know what a great job he's doing by, for instance, automatically correcting ERroneous capitalisation. He's looking at me now, having popped up when I typed that deliberate error.

There's a puppy-like hopeful smile on his face, as if he's expecting a biscuit. He makes me fidgety
and a little bit cross.

The Ubuntu people know all this, of course. At least, the ones with any hint of ambition to get the OS into the mass market do.

click to view full size imageThe advent of the netbook presented the perfect opportunity, but the ball was well and truly dropped. With Microsoft producing a netbook version of Windows XP - for emerging markets at least - and Windows 7 running just fine if you turn the fancy bits off, netbook Linux is on the rocks.

It's a cruel and ironic fact that even though Ubuntu Netbook Remix is a totally solid, stable, usable and free operating system, I'm just not that fired up about it.

There's innovation here, but not enough. There's some hint of a focused, resolute attempt to produce an OS for everyone, but not enough.

Lurking behind the veneer of spinning icons is the feeling that the grassroots Linux developers don't really want the unwashed mass getting their grubby paws on their lovely, ugly operating system.

They're going to carry on lurking in the shadows, wet fish in hand, ready to strike. They want a learning curve. They want you to have to use the command line. Damn it, they want you to suffer.


For more Linux adventures by David Fearon, also see his 7 day experiment with Linux.

See more about:  life  |  linux  |  special  |  edition  |  back  |  linux  |  ubuntu  |  netbook  |  remix  |  reviewed
 
 
Comments: 4
hellanwell
14 January 2010
Of course changing or using a new o/s will be a learning curve but Ubuntu is really easy to use and is a viable alternative to mac or windows. I agree with you about the open office clippy type character but in a world of many locked in standards odt is the only choice for open office as default. You also can save it in many other formats and due to the large user base of open office it is a recognized format even for microsoft.
As for your 'fact' about linux 'losing' netbook share the figure you are refering to is out of date 2009 figures show a 32% linux share dispite how hard it is to find in a store that is a world figure by the way not just a US figure http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9140343/Linux_s_share_of_netbooks_surging_not_sagging_says_analyst Even Dell in the US say Linux sells 15% of netbooks for them.Open source is everywhere and linux is just a part of that,in my shop I now have conversations with more and more people about Linux that they start not me! At the end of the day Linux is good for the consumer as it puts pressure on microsoft in short prices have to be lower to compete. Thats why netbooks are not poplar with microsoft.
As for mass market being shunned by geeks there maybe some who feel that but they won't be using ubuntu they will be using Gentoo or some other distribution you see in open source that is what you get- choice.


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
My life with Linux special edition: Going back to Linux with Ubuntu Netbook Remix?
After declaring his 7 day experiment with Linux over, David Fearon treks back into wild Linux country one more time, but returns somewhat disappointed

What do you think? Join the discussion.
Greg Prine
15 January 2010
I am beginning to believe you are a troll who is looking for affimation.

After the last article, there were many comments and emails sent to you explaining the common mistakes and ideas that permeated your ramblings. I think you receive such a response last time, you had to repeat it, to show it was not a fluke.


hiippari
25 January 2010
"Just try clicking on the Rhythmbox music player, for instance. Actually, don't: it's too awful and I wouldn't want to inflict the trauma on anyone" If you don't like it, switch to another one. If you don't know how to use the repositories, packet managers, or even google, it is not the problem of the OS. Like noted above by Greg, you are looking like a troll. There is a _TON_ of media players available for *nix systems. (for instance with a quick glance... http://sourceforge.net/search/?type_of_search=soft&words=media+player&search=Search over 4000 results of which actual players would range about 400-800 with 10-20 major ones)

Regarding ODT and openoffice... if you don't know how to switch a format in save prompt, and refuse to learn how, it is not an issue with openoffice. docx, doc, rtf, txt and other options are _CLEARLY_ marked and available. What you are saying is the same as sending your mom an docx and learning that she has an old 95 Word version installed and ranting about Microsoft doing BS products with no backwards compatibility (which actually is true in some cases, where new software does not run in old windows, like 98). Or similarly if you were to use regular mail and use less postage than needed and whining when the letter never goes out about the poor customer service... Or lets say trying to add someone in your MSN messenger list who is using IRC and complaining that the network protocols for windows do not work with this version.

User ignorance is never the reason why something "sucks".

As a conclusion, I am amazed how your article got even published. It has factual issues and you seem to have a bias. If you do not learn how to move around the _new_ OS and how to work with it, do not ask for help and refuse to check into things then I have to say that you are a troll.
hiippari
25 January 2010
And when it comes to ugly operating systems... Windows is _way_ behind Linux on the eye-candy. Go ahead and check into that one. No wait. I forgot. Let me provide a link. No wait... maybe a couple.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E4Fbk52Mk1w

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-CgqWlX_GsI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xC5uEe5OzNQ

And just as a background, do not say that those were copied from OS X or from MS. Check into it. And do us all a favor and DO YOUR RESEARCH!
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

Which broadband network do you think is the best choice for Australia?



or View results
The Coalition's.
  19%
 
Labor's.
  63%
 
Screw this I'm going back to smoke signals and string on a can.
  18%
TOTAL VOTES: 1713

Vote now
Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads