search technology reviews, news, features, group tests
Popular Searches:   video , dell , dvd
 |  Register
 |  Newsletters  | 
Sitemap  |  RSS
RSS
Monday November 23, 2009 8:00 AM AEST
Skip Navigation LinksPC Authority > News > Picking the Perfect Home Entertainment Box: Do you need a Freeview sticker?
Picking the Perfect Home Entertainment Box: Do you need a Freeview sticker?
NEWS

Picking the Perfect Home Entertainment Box: Do you need a Freeview sticker?

by Adam Turner  on Sep 24, 2009
"tribedenis wrote: but no salesperson I have encountered tells the whole story. Denis They'd be drummed out of the guild.:shock: 8-["
 
If you're buying a digital TV set top box you'll have likely noticed those Freeview stickers. But do you need it?

Part 5: The Freeview sticker on set top boxes reveals more about their limitations than their features.

The Freeview consortium would have you believe that you need to look for a PVR or set top box with a Freeview sticker to ensure it's compatible with digital TV. That's certainly not the case. In fact, opting for a Freeview-endorsed product actually means giving up a few features.

First the positives - the Freeview logo ensures your device has at least one high-def tuner and is MPEG-4-compatible (features you'll also find on many non-Freeview devices).

Even if you don't have a high-def television, high-def tuners are useful because they let you watch the high-def channels (albeit downscaled to stand-def on a standard television). The networks went through a phase of broadcasting different shows on their HD channels, but they seem to have abandoned the practice with the introduction of second standard-def channels.

Flicking through this week's guide, the only different content on the HD channels was Harry's Practice and The Great Outdoors on 7 HD. Remember, Ten's One HD is simulcast in SD so you're not missing anything there.

Australian digital television is broadcast in the MPEG-2 format but may eventually switch to the more efficient MPEG-4 standard - which would free up spectrum for more channels and other services.

When the switchover happens, devices with MPEG-2 tuners will be rendered useless. The MPEG-4 issue has been used as scare campaign to encourage people to opt for Freeview gear, but the fact is that the government and the broadcasters haven't announced an MPEG-4 switchover date.

Analogue TV won't be phased out until the end of 2013 and it would be political suicide for the government to render MPEG-2 equipment obsolete soon after, so it's a fair bet that MPEG-2 equipment has at least five years left in it.

Then there's the downside to the Freeview sticker. Ad-skipping must be disabled in Freeview-endorsed devices, they're only allowed to jump forwards or backwards a minimum of 10 minutes. Fast-forwarding and rewinding is limited to 30x. PVR manufacturers such as Beyonwiz and Topfield have removed ad-skipping from some models in order to get the Freeview logo.

Freeview-endorsed recorders must also be locked down to prevent you from copying recordings off the device - another requirement Beyonwiz and Topfield met with their dumbed-down Freeview-endorced models.

Somehow TiVo managed to side-step this Freeview restriction, as you can pay extra for the TiVo Home Networking package which lets you copy recordings to a computer.

There's a lot to consider when buying digital television equipment, but don't place too much importance on the Freeview logo.

Also in this series, Picking the Perfect Home Entertainment Box:
Part 4: What's the best way to record your favourite shows?
Part 3: networking your TV, PVR, console, set top box
Part 2: creating a P2P season pass
Part 1: Internet video on the PS3

Buying a TV? Also see our series How to Pick a Great Flat Screen TV, And Not Get Sucked In By Marketing Hype

Email a Friend Email this
Print Page Print this
Tweet This Tweet this
Feedback Send us your tips


Ads by Google

Comments: 6
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
gnome
Sep 24, 2009 2:39 PM
Things are not always what they seem (or are claimed to be) in TV-land. How surprising.


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Picking the Perfect Home Entertainment Box: Do you need a Freeview sticker??
If you're buying a digital TV set top box you'll have likely noticed those Freeview stickers. But do you need it?

What do you think? Join the discussion.
tribedenis
Sep 24, 2009 7:33 PM
I'm still trying to work out why anyone would need a high definition set top box, and yet 95% of floor stock in shops is high def.
As you point out, the only channel with different programs on HD is channel 7 - merely because they have yet to commit to an alternate format for the second channel. When they do commit, they also will have everything on HD simulcast in SD (I believe this is an ACMA requirement).
My concern has always been for the non-technical who are sold something they will not require, for at least twice the price.
Denis
Slatts
Sep 24, 2009 7:56 PM
Good heavens Denis, you sound like you may be a cynic.

Nobody likes to think that someone else might be getting something they're not.

Of course the good news is that the price of HD set top boxes is dropping to not a whole lot more than the SD boxes.

Meanwhile I'll stick to watching HD content on my computer and SD on the TV.

petergaskin
Sep 25, 2009 9:16 PM
If you choose a sd tv, then you will probably want to watch a hd program. Even though you dont get hd quality on an old tv, at least you get to see all possible programs.
tribedenis
Sep 27, 2009 3:03 PM
Hi Peter - that's my point - ALL programs will be broadcast on SD, once channel 7 pull their finger out, so the only reason to have HD is if you have an HD screen to view the great quality on, but - wait a minute, don't all Full HD TV's have a high definition tuner built in?
Yes Slatts. I must admit to being "somewhat" cynical with the retail market, but HD boxes are almost twice the price, with some going as high as 5 times the price. O.K. if you realise what you are buying, but no salesperson I have encountered tells the whole story.
Denis
Slatts
Sep 27, 2009 4:02 PM
tribedenis wrote:
but no salesperson I have encountered tells the whole story.
Denis

They'd be drummed out of the guild.:shock: 8-[
Login or register to submit a comment.
 

Top Stories

Box battle: Telstra takes on TiVo and Foxtel with T-Box trial in Melbourne
It's not quite Foxtel IQ and it's isn't TiVo either. The T-Box lets Telstra users watch movies and TV from the Bigpond site, as well as record and watch digital TV
 
5 More Free Linux Apps You Can't Do Without
More digital Swiss Army knife software, including Linux utilities and tools that are so useful you won't know how you ever did without them
 
Microsoft delivers Office 2010 public beta
Vendor details editions for Office 2010 along with application virtualisation for testing.
 


 
Intel
 
 
LogMeIn
 
 
Amazing Dell Coupons now available
 
Discover Apple