search technology reviews, news, features, group tests
Popular Searches:   asus , netbook , acer
 |  Register
 |  Newsletters  | 
Sitemap  |  RSS
RSS
Wednesday February 10, 2010 6:42 AM AEST
Skip Navigation LinksPC Authority > News > Netbook or laptop? Which is best for portable computing?
Netbook or laptop? Which is best for portable computing?
NEWS

Netbook or laptop? Which is best for portable computing?

by William Maher  on May 15, 2009
"Hi I have used a 7" eee PC a 8.9" HP 2133, 15" Dells & a 17" Macron. at present I have a 14" HP and a 12" DV2 my favourite, the DV2 it is small but the screen is very easy to read. and when at ..."
 
If you're wondering if a netbook is the perfect laptop for you, ask yourself this: will you want to work or play on your new laptop for hours at a time whilst viewing a screen 10 inches in size?

With high-end netbooks creeping up to the $1000 mark - and in the case of Sony's Vaio P series, well beyond it - the bigger question is whether you should be buying a netbook at all.

What about one that copes well with basic tasks, but gets a bit sluggish when you start opening lots of programs at once - especially if they are processor-intensive tasks such as watching video?

As long as you're happy with the small screen size and lack of processing power - we've found that even the new Atom N280 netbook processor can struggle running lots of programs at the same time under Windows XP - netbooks are a great mini laptop for the bus or train, or for around the house or for the kids.

On the other side of the coin, for around the same price as a high end netbook ($800-$900) you can get a full-size laptop with a much bigger screen and full size keyboard, and a CPU that will cope with Windows Vista (which most netbooks can't do).

If something small and light is your priority, look to fully-fledged mini-laptops with Core 2 Duo processors. Prices vary but at the very low end we've seen a 12in laptop with Intel's T5670 Core 2 Duo processor for $1100.

You'll be getting a bigger screen and keyboard, in some cases better battery life and more hard drive space, and the machine should be able to run Windows more smoothly, though it won't be a powerhouse.

Another bigger cousin to the netbook is AMD's Neo brand. Sitting between a netbook and full-sized laptop, the Neo is designed to be the next step up from a netbook.

The first and so far only Neo-equipped laptop is HP's DV2, which should be on sale by the time you read this. It has a 12.1in screen - much better for several hours of Web browsing or work - and the kinds of features you'd expect on a full size laptop, like a DVD drive and HDMI.

In theory it should also run Windows better than a netbook, though that's something we're yet to test. It's also a lot pricier, starting at $1399.

The dark horse of laptops

The dark horses in the race to build the Next Big Thing in laptops are Nvidia and ARM. Laptops using Nvidia's Tegra chip could be even cheaper than netbooks, though there were none at the time of writing.

Linux netbooks with ARM chips might also arrive overseas this year.

The potential advantage looks like being price, as ARM netbooks will reportedly sell for around US$200. As we went to press we'd seen no hardware, let alone any information about whether these machines would be sold in Australia.

If you still can't decide between a netbook and a laptop, our guide to Picking Your Perfect Laptop in the June edition of PC Authority gives you the complete picture. We've covered budget laptops, thin and light machines, and gaming and performance laptops, plus whether now is a good time to buy. The June issue is on sale now at your local newsagency.

 

Email a Friend Email this
Print Page Print this
Tweet This Tweet this
Feedback Send us your tips


Ads by Google

Comments: 3
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
totoaus
May 19, 2009 5:49 PM
Well, personally I think this article is almost a time-waster. Everyone's needs differ so widely you can only pretend to be helpful as it is so general.
In my own experience updated by regualr research(including access to a 10" netbook, plus past ownership or 12, 13, 14 & 15.4 laptops) I would not recommend less than 14" screen to anyone, simply for readability. For cost, the lowest price point is 15-15.5" apart from netbooks. 14 inch is also nice because while still quite light, you can usually pack anything you want into this size machine. One example, go to lenovo.com.au and configure a T400 (I did, 8 GB RAM, 320 GB HDD or 128 GB SSD, Blu-Ray burner, plus a slot for a second HDD (250 GB Full Disk Encryption), docking station, external screen, dual web cams, HSDPA. I configured a $10,000 system that was both portable and desktop, suitable for the highest end work including games, graphic design, movie editing and even EDA (my specialty need, aka IC design). Another example for high end userrs would be to look at AlienWare, but you only get 15 or 17 inch choices and can weasily configure $12,000 laptops (but they appear worth the price, apart from no Blu-Ray burner last I looked). For every other use, I'd advise people to simply go and buy whatever meets their price point, with a preference to Lenovo, Sony, Toshiba or other top tier brands. I find that most people who ask, follow my advice.


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Netbook or laptop? Which is best for portable computing??
If you're wondering if a netbook is the perfect laptop for you, ask yourself this: will you want to work or play on your new laptop for hours at a time whilst viewing a screen 10 inches in size?


What do you think? Join the discussion.
totoaus
May 19, 2009 5:57 PM
Oops, I forgot something! There is little more disatisfying than a machine failing. This is why I recommend the brands I do, they stand out by having extendable warranties. Lenovo for example, offers warranty upgrades to 3 years, that can include on-site service, accident protection (nice to know you can get a smashed screen covered), and even home & business online back-up solutions for your full system (laptop, plus accessories).
Also, a new idea: no matterhow powerful the laptop, I still refuse to give up on a high power desktop PC. I often advise people to think really seriously if they NEED a laptop at all, at least 50% of all the laptops I've ever supported NEVER leave the desk, and are badly set up ergonomically. This wastes money, destroys batteries, promotes ill-health and just does not makes sense as desktops are designed for this purpose and cost less.
Vulpine Blue
Dec 11, 2009 9:15 PM
Hi I have used a 7" eee PC a 8.9" HP 2133, 15" Dells & a 17" Macron. at present I have a 14" HP and a 12" DV2 my favourite, the DV2 it is small but the screen is very easy to read. and when at home I hook it up to a 19" monitor it is light and easy to use what more do you need.
Login or register to submit a comment.
 

Top Stories

20 hot technologies to watch in 2010: The GPU/CPU
Number 11: There's a very big year ahead in processors, with more than a few game-changers on the horizon. Six-core and eight-core processors, 32nm manufacturing and more will appear this year.
 
Top 10 best Apple products of all time
Next week in San Francisco will be the annual Macworld Expo in San Francisco, so we figured it was time to look at all things Apple..
 
Ericsson readies demo of 84Mbit/s HSPA
Ericsson has announced that it will give the world's first demonstration of 84Mbit/s High Speed Packet Access (HSPA) technology at the Mobile World Congress event in Barcelona later this month..
 


 
PC Authority Software Store

Uniblue SpeedUpMyPC

RRP: AU$39.95
Save: AU$18.00 (45%)

Our Price: AU$21.95

PC Authority Software Store   PC Authority Software Store

 
 
LogMeIn
 
 
Back to Work
 
1) Apple iPhone 3GS 16GB30 plans 1%
2) HTC Magic16 plans 6%
3) Nokia E7149 plans 1%
4) Apple iPhone 8GB42 plans 9%
5) HTC Touch Diamond211 plans 1%
1) iiNet32 plans 1%
2) Netspace36 plans 7%
3) TPG Internet19 plans 10%
4) Optus33 plans 4%
5) Telstra BigPond30 plans 15%

Mobiles | Broadband | Credit Cards

PC Authority