Monday March 22, 2010 10:51 PM AEST
Skip Navigation LinksPC Authority > News > Sony’s new XBR Bravia: LED backlighting explained
Lenovo: Linux is too hard, too complex and not what the customer wants
NEWS

Lenovo: Linux is too hard, too complex and not what the customer wants

by Daniel Long  on Apr 22, 2009

A Lenovo analyst has declared his disinterest in Linux, claiming that Microsoft is easier and better to use for the consumer and that Linux is too technical to ever take off. Agree?

In a rather frank conversation with Tech Blorge, Lenovo's Worldwide Competitive Analyst, Matt Kohut, has claimed that Linux is a fading fanboy's dream and most people will more than happy to stick with Windows in the long run.

Speaking from Sydney, Kohut predicted that Linux is in for a less than rosy future. Suggesting its limited niche appeal, Kohut was quick to shoot down ideas of Linux taking off outside of netbooks, citing poor hardware and vendor support, and it being too tricky to navigate for the average user.

In one mind boggling quote, Kohut declared to Tech Blorge that Linux would always be a niche player:

 "Linux in netbooks and notebooks I don't think is ever going to happen," he said. It's a strange comment to make, considering that Linux is alive and well in the expanding netbook space.

In Europe, some countries have made Linux a national priority (Spain and Portugal for example), seeking the cost savings that come with dumping Windows in schools and government departments. Linux.org provides a detailed and official list of various governments around the world running Linux as as operating system alternative.

Kohut noted that the savings made by choosing a Linux based computer were not a good return on a customer's money, citing an unspecified number of ‘netbook returns' for the basis of his comment. Generally, Kohut believes that customers have found the Linux OS too difficult to use and too technical to understand.

"Linux, even if you've got a great distribution and you can argue which one is better or not, still requires a lot more hands-on than somebody who is using Windows... You have to know how to decompile codes and upload data, stuff that the average person, well, they just want a computer."

No doubt, Lenovo are in damage control right now, as there are bound to be an army of knife wielding Linux fans outraged by Kohut's comments. However Microsoft are probably pleased as punch with Lenovo's pro-windows stance.

 

""Nobody ever got fired for specifying Micro$oft". That's a lousy reason for buying anything, but peter_g100 is dead right about the alternative OS needing to become more user friendly to the ..."
 
APRIL PC AUTHORITY - ON SALE NOW
In our AMD vs Intel CPU megatest we rate 50 of the best on the market - from budget to performance.
15 Internet Security Software packages get a going over in our 'torture test'.
Plus, we look at what works and what fails in MS Office 2010 and tell you how to try it - for free.
Email a Friend Email this
Print Page Print this
Tweet This Tweet this
Feedback Send us your tips


Ads by Google

Comments: 3
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
future.shock
Apr 22, 2009 3:38 PM
B.....ks! While I acknowledge that linux is only just at the 'average user' doorstep, there can be no doubt that progress is being made at lightning speed. In a world saturated by those with extreme vested interests it's refreshing to see the inevitable success of linux. Guys you're playing the game and losing. Give it up for linux!


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Lenovo: Linux is too hard, too complex and not what the customer wants?
A Lenovo analyst has declared his disinterest in Linux, claiming that Microsoft is easier and better to use for the consumer and that Linux is too technical to ever take off. Agree?

What do you think? Join the discussion.
peter_g100
Apr 22, 2009 3:42 PM
Linux on the early netbooks was pretty usable for what these devices did. The focus was on doing a few tasks adequately without the need to carry a full computer around. Add in ASUS' neat interface, and it was pretty much like a mobile phone to use.

The more sophisticated these devices became, though, the more suited Windows was for the user, because people wanted to add their favourite applications and have an almost full-function notebook for the price. That is where Linux falls down.

Ubuntu (for example) is vastly better than even Mandrake version 8 was a couple of years ago, and not a lot more difficult to use than Windows. But, by comparison with Windows or Macs, things like installing applications are still more difficult, support for printers and other peripherals is not as good, and installation of these devices is not as simple. If people are already a bit iffy because the OS is different and a little more complex, and then are faced with a less straightforward process to get what they want up and running, many will give up before they have even tried hard.

If the Linux camp wants their product taken up seriously by general users, they need to look very hard at what general users expect of a computer, and provide it. The OS is no longer quite a geek's system any more, but it still hasn't quite crossed over into being a general consumer's OS.
gnome
Apr 22, 2009 6:13 PM
"Nobody ever got fired for specifying Micro$oft".

That's a lousy reason for buying anything, but peter_g100 is dead right about the alternative OS needing to become more user friendly to the great unwashed.
Login or register to submit a comment.
 

Top Stories

Canon DSLR Buyer's Guide: we compare the mid-range cameras
Want to buy a mid-range Canon SLR? Like the look of the new 550D? Confused by the large range? We're here to help.
 
Skype's global WiFi service a big price gouge for travellers?
Skype Access will now offer WiFi internet access in thousands of locations worldwide. But don't get too excited, a quick scan of the pricing and we're not so enthusiastic
 
Broadcom claims world’s fastest single-chip Ethernet switch
The new Broadcom switch line up aims to bring high-speed switching to all.
 


 
1) Apple iPhone 3GS 16GB36 plans 29%
2) Nokia E7228 plans 7%
3) Nokia N97 Mini27 plans 10%
4) Nokia E7147 plans 7%
5) Sony Ericsson Aino6 plans 2%
1) Netspace36 plans 3%
2) iiNet32 plans 7%
3) Telstra BigPond30 plans 3%
4) Optus41 plans 6%
5) 37 plans 2%

Mobiles | Broadband | Credit Cards

Haymarket - PC Authority