Network Video Players

Browse this article:  Prev   Next

How we test
Plus how we work out the ratings
We test network video players by attempting to play a diverse range of video files on each model to find out which has the widest format support. We also test music and photo support, and assess the overall user experience with each device, since format support isn’t the only consideration.

At the bottom of each review, you’ll find four ratings: Performance, Features & Design, Value for Money and Overall. We don’t pluck these out of the air; they’re calculated using a mixture of objective and subjective ratings.

The Performance score is a combination of each unit’s responsiveness to remote-control commands, its image quality and how many of our test files it was able to play. For the tests, we use a Sony VAIO notebook as the “server” PC. This runs Windows XP Media Center Edition, and we install Windows Media Player 11 so it has the latest version of Windows Media Connect.

We load the library with around 20GB of music, photos and videos, including standard and high-definition WMV files. The full list of test files is as follows: WMV, WMV-HD (720p), DivX (SD, AVI), XviD (SD, AVI), H.264, VOB, FLV, QuickTime (720p), QuickTime (SD). Naturally, not all these formats are supported by Windows Media Player, so we install the bundled media-server software for each device and check if any extra formats are supported, and whether performance is better or worse.

We connect the notebook to a D-Link DIR-655 wireless router using an Ethernet cable to ensure there are no bottlenecks, and connect each video streamer wirelessly to the router using WPA/WPA2 security.

We then try playing each type of video in turn to find out if it plays smoothly (both video and audio) or if it can’t be played at all. Our second test is to view a photo slideshow; we look at the transitions and general responsiveness. Finally, we play a few different music albums, and check whether tracks are listed in the correct order and whether album art is picked up correctly.

We repeat all these tests by accessing the files from a USB flash drive where devices have USB ports, again noting whether the videos stutter or don’t play at all.

Browse this article:  Prev   Next

This Group Test appeared in the March, 2008 issue of PC & Tech Authority Magazine

See more about:  network  |  video  |  players
Comments: 2
20 June 2008
RAID1 is *not* backup. RAID makes access to data more more reliable, but do not be lulled into a false sense of security. RAID may reduce the chance of losing data due to drive failure but it is no protection against losing your data due to other means, e.g. user error.

Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Network Video Players?
Play your video, photo and music files on your TV from a networked PC. We put five network players to the test

What do you think? Join the discussion.
20 June 2008
You seem to have missed some of the more popular options available for network streaming.

* Softmodded Xbox classic and Xbox Media Centre (XBMC) - my personal favourite for Standard Def.
* MediaGate 450HD
* Popcorn Hour A100
* ZIOVA Clearstream devices

XBMC for Linux on a SFF PC has the best outlook for HD streaming. When it comes out of beta. Any other HD streaming device seems to be a compromise in some way or another - mainly the user interface.

Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

What PC component are you planning to upgrade in the next six months

Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads