Sunday March 21, 2010 11:10 AM AEST
Skip Navigation LinksPC Authority > Features > Broadband Buyer's Guide: Fixed vs Mobile
Broadband Buyer's Guide: Fixed vs Mobile
»
FEATURE

Broadband Buyer's Guide: Fixed vs Mobile

by Barry Collins  on Apr 1, 2009

Could you really replace your home or business broadband with a mobile dongle? Our broadband buyer's guide names the best plans, the most attractive deals and the best value for money.

Mobile broadband is on the march. Many people have already been won over by the promise of broadband that goes wherever they go, and - more importantly - doesn't require them to pay twice: once for the broadband and once for the phone line. So should you be preparing to join them?

In this feature, we'll examine whether mobile broadband, Naked DSL or ADSL - or a combination of the three possibilities - is the best option for various different types of lifestyle.

From light surfers to hard-core gamers to small businesses, we'll be delivering our verdict on which option makes the most sense for their particular needs.

We'll also be recommending specific broadband packages for each of the different lifestyle categories, based on our own tests and the feedback of 20,000 PC Authority readers from our recent Reliability and Service survey.

We've pushed mobile broadband to its very limits, to see just how far a 3G data connection will stretch in both the workplace and the home.

We'll also be examining what effect the various types of USB dongle have on connection speeds, examining how regional speeds compare to metropolitan maximums and testing newly released 3G routers to see if they deserve a place in your home or business.

Our speed tests of all of the Australian mobile broadband networks revealed that mobile broadband is really only a practical option in areas covered by a strong 3G network. In areas blessed with High Speed Download Packet Access (HSDPA) connections, actual throughput speeds greater than 6Mbits/sec are a genuine possibility. In areas that only have GPRS connections, you're looking at sub-1Mbit/sec speeds or much worse.

With regional Australia and New Zealand, the situation is worse - GPRS speeds may be all you can hope to attain. So, before committing to any mobile broadband network, check coverage maps on the network's website to ensure you're in a 3G area.

Better still, grab a mobile phone on the network you're planning to use and check it can get a 3G signal in any room you plan to use your broadband connection from, since signal strength can vary from building to building.


Light Surfersclick to view full size image

Those who only use their home internet connection for a little light surfing and email are those who potentially have the most to gain from a move to mobile broadband. And we're not only talking about internet newbies here: there are probably plenty of IT professionals who are so sick of staring at a screen all day that they barely touch the internet when they arrive home.

Even in June 2008, there were a surprising 800,000 wireless broadband subscriptions - 14% of all internet accounts - according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, and that was before mobile broadband had reached the mainstream market. How many of the remaining 85% were keeping their landline just to maintain a broadband connection?

With Telstra charging $25 a month for line rental - before you even get to the monthly broadband fee - the economics of mobile broadband are very attractive. "Some people are using mobile broadband so they could scrap the line rental," said Andrew Ferguson, editor of Thinkbroadband.com.

With networks such as 3 and Virgin offering mobile broadband from as little as $20 per month, it can actually represent a saving on the landline alone. "You almost get the broadband for free if you think of it that way," Ferguson adds.

Ferguson believes that mobile broadband suits a particular type of home user. "Those most likely to switch are people with a bit of light usage - people who are doing a bit of shopping, a bit of banking, and not much else."

Many people are put off mobile broadband by the relatively restrictive data caps. The limits on the cheaper plans are often 1GB or less, and for mobile broadband, unlike ADSL, uploads and downloads are counted toward your quota.

Yet, even those who consider themselves "heavy" internet users tend to overestimate the amount of data they actually need. The average internet user consumes 2-3GB of data a month, although Ferguson said that some ISPs believe that figure is climbing nearer to 10GB. Nonetheless, those who use a broadband connection only for web browsing and email will never come close to even 2GB.

Light internet users are also more likely to be single-PC households, which are better suited to mobile broadband than multiple PC setups, because you can plug the dongle into your PC and be up and running within a minute or two, without having to worry about how you're going to split the connection.

Best broadband deal?

If you can survive on a 1Gb ration a month and it isn't as restrictive as you might think - then 3's $15 per month Broadband Lite option offers great value.

For those outside metropolitan areas, 3 is considerably more expensive: consider Dodo's 1GB monthly plan, which is $18 per month on a two-year deal and uses Optus' network. In New Zealand, Whoosh's $29 1GB plan is the best deal, though coverage outside of metropolitan areas can be patchy.

 

"If your in the bush (well more than an hour away from a major city) it isn't really worth getting mobile broadband there just isn't the support for it unless you live in the main street and even ..."
 
Copyright © 2009 Dennis Publishing
This article appeared in the April, 2009 issue of PC Authority.
»
APRIL PC AUTHORITY - ON SALE NOW
In our AMD vs Intel CPU megatest we rate 50 of the best on the market - from budget to performance.
15 Internet Security Software packages get a going over in our 'torture test'.
Plus, we look at what works and what fails in MS Office 2010 and tell you how to try it - for free.
Email a Friend Email this
Print Page Print this
Tweet This Tweet this
Feedback Send us your tips


Ads by Google

Comments: 6
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
peterh_oz
Apr 2, 2009 2:50 AM
Its a shame the author didn't fully research all the options out there. Exetel have some great pricing, mostly zero contract wireless (you buy the unlocked modem from them), and ALL plans now include 100 free VoIP calls per month, plus 30 SMSs and 20 Faxes every month (additional SMS 8c and fax 3c).

Also ALL plans come with $15 cashback if connected via www.SeeknBuy.com.au.

Occasional usage: $5/month + 1.5c/Mb
Low end usage: 1Gb = $17.50, 2Gb = $22.50
Medium - high usage: 5Gb = $37.50, 8Gb = $50 (higher than the "highest" non-telstra 7Gb mentioned in the article)

They run on the Optus network and therefore have much more coverage than 3's, and without the 2 year contract required by Dodo (cheaper monthly fee too!)

Also their ADSL1 plans start at $40. ADSL2 plans start from $40 + a tiny $15 line rental for 6Gb + 60Gb offpeak (noon/midnight again) AND the same included 100 voip calls + 30 SMS + 20 faxes. Naked ADSL2 starts from $45. They also have plans with non-expiring prepaid data, starting at $30 (ADSL1) or $25 (ADSL2 plus $15 line rental).

They also do mobile phone plans - again at significantly cheaper rates (cap plans which include a wad of data - 50-300Mb, and normal plans with data packs available, PLUS 3G plans with phone calls attached). And they actually encourage VoIP use from your mobile, rather than restricting it like the big telcos (Optus!).

Again use the $15 cashback from www.SeeknBuy.com.au to offset the connection fee.


Comment made about the PC Authority article:
Broadband Buyer's Guide: Fixed vs Mobile?
Could you really replace your home or business broadband with a mobile dongle? Our broadband buyer's guide names the best plans, the most attractive deals and the best value for money.

What do you think? Join the discussion.

Edited by peterh_oz: 2/4/2009 03:03:04 AM
Flogger
Jun 1, 2009 3:44 PM
We used 3 for about 6 months and it is truly terrible. It is grindingly slow, the service drops out randomly and the hardware is faulty.

Combine all that with truly appalling customer service and it is safe to say we will never use 3, for anything, ever again.

Honestly, to anyone out there considering 3 because it appears to be a cheap option upfront do not be fooled by the initial cheap price. It is a false economy as the service, speed and quality is pathetic.
Slatts
Jun 1, 2009 7:30 PM
Hmmm...
I think I see a trend starting to take shape here flogger.
Have you just joined the forum to warn everyone about 3 or do you have something else to talk about?
Don't get me wrong. I enjoy a bit of web based revenge as much as the next bloke...:twisted:
retta1
Nov 1, 2009 10:44 AM
We have the telstra mobile usb card and it is expensive but when we were out at fowlers bay just east of the nullabour we had reception with the antenna which for telstra is a decent price! i wouldn't reccomend it for the people who dont go anywhere out of the city tho. for a 5Gb plan it is $90.00 a month!
Chris - PC
Jan 9, 2010 1:13 PM
Fixed Vs Mobile... Is Mobile Technology Is Amazing? Or Is It A Waste Of Money?
Well We can use our current mobile network to surf the net anywhere. But it all depends on the network your using. Lots of different retailers advertise it at very cheap price but don't be fooled, you need to now what your buying. Telstra/Bigpond has a plan with excellent coverage but it comes at a very sharp price. But Telstra/Bigpond can do this as no other service provider can give the coverage they do.
As for fixed there is multiple options ranging from good quality to bad. Telstra/Bigpond is not leading in this battle in metro areas but in country and rural areas other service providers don't have the line quality and coverage that they provide. Comparing them both and the result is unknown.
Acehold
Jan 11, 2010 8:13 PM
If your in the bush (well more than an hour away from a major city) it isn't really worth getting mobile broadband there just isn't the support for it unless you live in the main street and even then it can be touch and go. I'm not a computer specialist just a backyard pc warrior, so don't flame me too hard here guys ... and girls. While i agree that for coverage in the bush the most stable will be Telstra/Bigpond if you are lucky and know a little about pcs and have updated all of your lines you can get service from DODO. I have them as my carrier and for $80 a month i recieve 100gb onpeak and 100gb offpeak, at 1.5mbps. Running a family network of 5 pcs its good. I can even run monthly LAN games for up to 8 kids and still get internet strong enough to play online team games. Most of the problems i have heard about dodo falls mainly on the language and training gap there staff suffer from, so if you cant handle accents you might run into some problems. other than that they have looked after me well these last 6 yrs.
Login or register to submit a comment.
 

Top Stories

Not in Australia, the innovative technologies you won't find here: paying with RFID
Paying for our goods with RFID technology might seem risky, but in some countries it's already commonplace. Can RFID payments be more than just an e-toll solution in Australia?
 
Vintage Tech: Looking back at 3DFX Voodoo
3DFX's technology was groundbreaking for its time, but the company is little but an Nvidia afterthought these days. What gave the Voodoo its special magic?
 
That pesky "water damage" phone issue: getting repairs could be tricky
Readers were telling us that repairers were claiming "water damage" as a reason for refusing to repair their phones. So what are your rights in this situation?
 


 
1) Apple iPhone 3GS 16GB36 plans 27%
2) Nokia E7228 plans 3%
3) Nokia E7147 plans 8%
4) Sony Ericsson Aino6 plans 3%
5) HTC Magic5 plans 3%
1) iiNet32 plans 5%
2) Netspace36 plans 11%
3) Optus41 plans 12%
4) 37 plans 6%
5) Telstra BigPond30 plans 4%

Mobiles | Broadband | Credit Cards

Haymarket - PC Authority