Apple iPhone 4S reviewed: is it a worthy upgrade?

Recommended
Apple iPhone 4S reviewed: is it a worthy upgrade?
Rating
Overall:

Everything you need to know about Apple's iPhone 4S, including design, Siri, the camera and IOS 5.0. Read our review.

Performance:
6
Features & Design:
5
Value for Money:
3
Price
Price: $799
> Pricing info
Specs
Price 799
Browse this Review:  Prev   Next

What’s new in iOS 5

It isn’t only about the iPhone 4S – owners of older handsets can get an upgrade too by downloading iOS 5, complete with several new features

Whether you’re buying a 4S or just updating your existing iPhone, the new version of iOS brings, if not a complete overhaul, then at least a level of much-needed refinement. We’ve installed it on the iPhone 4 and 3GS, as well as on the iPad 2, and while the process wasn’t totally smooth – we lost apps and settings on several devices – now the initial rush has passed, things will hopefully be easier.
 
At first glance iOS 5 doesn’t look new, but there are small signs: rounded sliders in menus, an optional split keyboard and tabbed browsing in Safari for iPad users. Twitter is now integrated, so you can share things from within the stock Apple apps. And it feels slicker and more responsive on devices new and old. 
 
Notifications
 
The first big change is to the way iOS 5 handles notifications. Previously, alerts would sledgehammer their way to the front of the screen, and they’d require your input to leave again. Now, they flash up discreetly in a bar at the top of the screen; if they’re not urgent, ignore them and they’ll vanish in a few seconds.
 
To see them all, swipe down from the top edge to reveal the Notification Centre. As well as messages, calls and mails, you can set apps to appear too – you get Weather and Stocks by default, but you can add Facebook or even Angry Birds if you want. They lack a nice widget like the weather one, but you can choose how many recent push notifications each will show.
 
It’s a big improvement over the clunky way things worked before, although it all feels rather familiar – particularly if you’ve used an Android device. We also had one or two issues with notifications becoming stuck – one persistent calendar entry drained our battery in mere hours.
 
iMessage
 
Less immediately obvious, but every bit as useful, is iOS 5’s approach to text messaging. Perhaps responding to the several popular free messaging apps atop the App Store, iOS 5 users can now talk to each other for free with no additional software required.
 
Type the recipient’s name into the Messages app, and the OS will check it against Apple’s servers. If it’s found, the Send button turns blue and your message is sent over your data connection. If it isn’t found, the button stays green and it’s sent as a normal charged text. It’s so simple most people won’t know even know that they’re using it. It is a genuine boon if your mobile plan charges for individual text messages, but its real genius is its transparency.
 
PC-free
No longer will you be forced to connect to your laptop or PC via USB. Set iTunes to allow the iOS 5 device to sync over Wi-Fi, and it will do just that – provided your laptop and device are on the same network. Note that the iPhone/iPad has to be plugged into the mains for Wi-Fi syncing to automatically occur; you can force it while running on battery from the Settings menu.
 
Future OS updates can also be obtained without connecting to a PC or Mac, and these have finally been revamped: rather than having to download the whole OS again, only the parts that have changed will need downloading. 
 
iCloud
iCloud is a reworking of MobileMe that retains the syncing of Mail, Contacts, Calendars and Bookmarks, but adds a few extra features. You can now sync your Camera Roll across multiple devices, with the last 1000 pictures sucked up to the cloud for free. In addition, the 5GB of storage Apple provides for free can now be filled from Pages, Numbers and Keynote, with saved documents automatically filtering to all of your synced devices. iOS 5 devices can also be backed up to the cloud, and apps can store documents and data there too.
 
Newsstand
One of the more disappointing introductions is Newsstand, Apple’s storefront for offering subscriptions and regular issues of magazines in app form. Right now, the selection is hardly stellar; navigation and search just kick you out to the Newsstand section in iTunes; and Apple’s insistence on labelling every title as free, rather than listing the in-app issue price, means most of the top titles are drowning in unfair one-star reviews from customers baffled that they can’t have a monthly magazine for nothing. The interface still needs quite a bit of work if it’s to reach the iTunes standard.
 
Our verdict
 
Aside from a few gripes – the upgrade teething troubles, glitch notifications and apps that won’t relinquish their grasp on the iPhone’s GPS when disabled – iOS 5 is a welcome upgrade. 
 
Notifications might be very Android-like, but they desperately needed a revamp, and we absolutely love iMessage. If you have an iOS device, there are few reasons not to upgrade.

 

This Review appeared in the Jan, 2012 issue of PC & Tech Authority Magazine

Source: Copyright © PC Pro, Dennis Publishing

Browse this Review:  Prev   Next
See more about:  iphone  |  4s  |  review  |  apple
 
 

Readers of this article also read...

First Look: MSI Z87 Mpower MAX Motherboard 

First Look: MSI Z87 Mpower MAX Motherboard

 
Exclusive First Look: Gigabyte's Z87X-UD3H 

Exclusive First Look: Gigabyte's Z87X-UD3H

 
Unboxed: LG's Optimus G "Superphone" 

Unboxed: LG's Optimus G "Superphone"

 
Google's new Chromebook Pixel bests MacBook Pro in the ppi war 

Google's new Chromebook Pixel bests MacBook Pro in the ppi war

 
Aliens: Colonial Marines screenshots 

Aliens: Colonial Marines screenshots

 
Comments: 6
photohounds
6 January 2012
"a level of much-needed refinement". I had a play with one, it's nice enough, but The finest screen? Well if your definition includes only pixel density and you judge displays with a magnifying glass - only just.

If a 'fine screen' includes usability, definitely NOT - especially for the over 35's who appreciate a little more to look at - or gamers, or other real people.

Elsewhere a lot of catching up has been done, that's good.

Meanwhile, Android has moved the goalposts, Ice Cream Sandwich appears slick and also has 400,000 apps to back it ... then there are the new phones, actual, imminent and rumoured.


While it is a nice phone and OS, other makers needn't worry in the least. They can (and will) just keep innovating to maintain the lead. Those flexible Sammy screens look interesting - a screen that looks like a screen protector :)









Edited by photohounds: 6/1/2012 01:52:40 PM
TheToid
6 January 2012
Siri requiring an A5 processor based device is definitely a load of crap, for a starters, certain hackers have used their iPhone 4S Key to run Siri on their iPhone 4, of course you still need a 4S key to authenticate Siri with the iPhone 4, but the processor requirement is a load of crap, see here for details:

http://www.iphonestuffs4u.com/spire-install-siri-for-iphone-4-3gs-ipad-ipod-touch/

I am disgusted with Apple that they think they need to lie to us, why couldnt they just tell the truth. "Siri is only available on the iPhone 4S because if everybody who owns an iPhone 4 gets it for free, then the infrastructure cost for us would be great compared to the profits we make." There was that so hard?
Tysio
7 January 2012
Unless you have money to throw away, then it wouldn't be best to go out of your way to upgrade to the 4s.
Sure there may be hardware improvements, but is it really worth to pay more just for a tad better performance?

I also hear that people can get Siri on the iPhone 4 so it doesn't really differentiate the iPhone 4s much.
If you haven't had an iPhone and want one and have the money, go for it!
But I don't think an upgrade is necessary..

http://www.ipad-ipod.com.au
amcmo
9 January 2012
Ah Photo, still on the screen size issue.

I'm SUBSTANTIALLY over 35, (my youngest of 6 is in her 30's) need reading glasses, and will probably be going to long distance glasses this year, however have absolutely no problems with the 4s screen.

One of our daughters now has a Galaxy 2S, (her choice) which I have played with. The much vaunted OLED screen is no better than the 4s screen, other than everything being slightly larger. (and bulkier)

Just in from the US, reports of the Nexus S screen being fragile and susceptible to cracking, plus your much vaunted Galaxy 2S being very susceptible to scratching - don't put the car keys in the same pocket. (and have you seen the latest Samsung phone that, apart from the camera opening looks EXACTLY like a 3GS iPhone,and strangely enough targeted at exactly the same market segment)

While we're on some of your usual favourite topics - the 'Dead Horse' antennae-gate you insist on flogging from time to time, affected less than 1. something percent of US based users in any meaningful way and was largely restricted to area's of the US where cellphone reception and traffic loading were issues. The Yanks have a very 3rd World cellphone infrastructure. Amazing, once it's looked at beyond the hype, it turns out to be largely just that - hype. Would have been long forgotten, without the endless Android fanboy bleating.
rubaiyat
10 January 2012
photohounds wrote:
Ice Cream Sandwich appears slick and also has 400,000 apps to back it ...


No it doesn't. Only a tiny fraction of those make even remote use of high resolution screens let alone ICS.

I'm still puzzled as to how you upgrade to ICS from prior Android devices and as to whether you get stuck with whatever the manufacturer stuck you with when you bought the gadget.

I've just played with the Galaxy Tab and am struck with how there is no obvious way out of the screen saver and similarly no obvious way to unlock when you get to the home page. It also felt less than smooth when zooming and the screen seemed less distinct than an iPad.

All that and it is still no cheaper. Although that probably won't stop you claiming it is.
photohounds
18 January 2012


Samsung's 30 pin connector is based on CEA's PDMI design, which is a standard, non-proprietary alternative to Apple's docking connector. So ... industry-standard (not copied from Apple).

Bigger, more useful screen, Narrower bezel, lots of connectivity options works with TVs and other DLNA devices - but where's the card slot??? :(

WHY should it be cheaper at this time? It's better.

And here ... a brief video of the upcoming galaxy S3?
http://androidadvices.com/samsung-president-shows-galaxy-s3-ces-press-conference/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+AndroidAdvices+%28Android+Advices%29

And Ruby, you can ICS a Galaxy - you have to root it, though.
If Aussie CARRIERS included CarrerIQ I'd be tempted - for now, it works just fine :)
Comments have been disabled for this article.

Latest Comments

Latest Poll

Which broadband network do you think is the best choice for Australia?



or View results
The Coalition's.
  19%
 
Labor's.
  63%
 
Screw this I'm going back to smoke signals and string on a can.
  18%
TOTAL VOTES: 1672

Vote now
Ads by Google

From our Partners

PC & Tech Authority Downloads